1. My top three, in no particular order: Batman Begins - Christian Bale is the best Batman, period (slight edge over Keaton), and the rest of the cast is awesome also; can't believe Frank Miller didn't get script credit though, plenty of nods to Year One and Dark Knight Returns. Tank Girl - fun movie, well-integrated comic-art cut scenes. Spider-Man 2 - both of Raimi's spider-movies are excellent, I'm just picking this one b/c Doc Oc was always one of my favorite baddies. Just missed my cut: Tim Burton's Batman, X-Men 2.
2. Worst three - so many to choose from here, and I haven't even seen the Fantastic Four or Hulk yet (although I know several people who really liked Hulk). And I'm not even going to link to Catwoman. I'm gonna have to go with Superman IV, which introduced us to Nuclear Man (anyone remember him?). Batman Forever, one of Schumacher's disasters, has to be next; could acting talent be wasted any more than Tommy Lee Jones' was as Two-Face? Fortunately, not many people saw the 1990 version of Captain America, which featured J.D. Salinger's actor son Matt as Captain A(wful).
Upcoming films, which certainly have the potential to make these lists:
- Jon Favreau-directed Iron Man, starring Robert Downey Jr., due out in 2008.
- Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer, 2007 release.
- Ghost Rider, starring Nicholas Cage. This could be spectacularly terrible.
- Wonder Woman, directed and written by Joss Whedon. Intriguing...
- Spider-Man 3, with Venom! I'm stoked, dudes!
- The Dark Knight, the next Nolan Batman, with Heath Ledger as the Joker (2008).
- X-Men prequel, Wolverine, 2008.